Save This For Later
We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
Whether you’re shopping for the holidays, picking out a birthday present, or just want to surprise a little one in your life, Milwaukee has some truly special locally owned toy stores and boutiques to explore.
From quirky games and classic toys to thoughtfully curated books and handmade outfits, these shops make it easy to find a meaningful gift — and support local businesses at the same time.
🎯 Art Smart’s Dart & Juggling Emporium
1695 N. Humboldt Ave., Milwaukee, WI 53202
This one-of-a-kind corner shop on Humboldt and Brady is packed with dartboards, juggling supplies, kites, boomerangs, disc golf gear, yo-yos, and novelty gifts. It’s a go-to spot for stocking stuffers and fun, active play. Some of their inventory is available online, and they offer free worldwide shipping on orders over $100.
🧩 Fischberger’s Variety
2445 N. Holton St., Milwaukee, WI 53212
Tucked in Riverwest, Fischberger’s is part toy shop, part old-school variety store — and all charm. You’ll find toys, games, puzzles, art supplies, greeting cards, candy, and more. Order online for pickup!
🎉 Ruckus & Glee
805 N. 68th St., Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Bright, colorful, and interactive, this shop is all about hands-on fun. Ruckus & Glee carries thoughtfully chosen toys, games, and books for kids of all ages and interests. They offer online shopping, curbside pickup, gift wrap, and even a Birthday Club and registry.
🧁 Winkie’s Hallmark & Gifts
629 E. Silver Spring Dr., Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
A local staple for generations, Winkie’s has a little bit of everything. Downstairs, you’ll find a wide selection of toys, games, and candy for kids. Upstairs features home décor, stationery, and gifts for grownups. It’s a true neighborhood favorite.
🍭 The Smiley Barn Toy & Candy Store
2420 Milwaukee St., Delafield, WI 53018
With roots going back to 1932, this whimsical shop is worth the drive. You’ll find classic toys, candy, interactive play areas, and ice cream at the on-site Mullen’s Dairy Bar. It’s a full-on nostalgic experience.
💡 Looking for more gift ideas? Don’t miss The Ultimate Guide to Shopping for Kids in Milwaukee: Books, Toys & Boutiques
More Helpful Reads:
Calie Herbst, Editor-in-Chief of Milwaukee With Kids, has spent over a decade combining her experiences as a parent of three to create a hub for Milwaukee’s family adventures.
Her decade-long teaching career in Milwaukee Public Schools and academic background, including a Master’s in Teaching from Marquette University and dual B.A.s in Sociology and Spanish from the University of Wisconsin – Madison, fuel her passion for inclusive and engaging family content.
Calie is also a recognized voice in local media, contributing to WISN Channel 12 News, WTMJ Wisconsin Morning News, Fox 6’s Real Milwaukee, and B93.3.
Discover more about Calie’s journey and editorial approach on her About Page and Editorial Policy Page.
